11/02/2018 Jenny Gumbert

Common Hour Speaker Embraces Uncomfortable Conversations


When audience members entered Franklin & Marshall College’s Mayser Gymnasium Nov. 1 and sat down with their free pizza slices, they likely did not expect to be asked to embrace discomfort. But the day’s speaker, Megan Red Shirt-Shaw, had a task that she was ready to assign. 

“I am going to challenge every single one of you to be and stay uncomfortable, taking time to acknowledge your own privileges and non-privileges,” Red Shirt-Shaw said. 

Throughout her talk during F&M’s Common Hour, a community conversation conducted each week classes are in session, Red Shirt-Shaw alternated these calls for leaning into discomfort with encouraging messages for students, particularly students of Native heritage. Ultimately, she spoke to inspire the next generation to pave the way for progress. 

Red Shirt-Shaw, an enrolled member of the Oglala Sioux tribe, is founder of “Natives In America,” an online literary publication for Native American, Alaska Native and Native Hawaiian youth. She is currently pursuing a doctorate in organizational leadership, policy and development with a focus on higher education at the University of Minnesota.

  • Megan Red Shirt-Shaw tells the Nov. 1 Common Hour audience that they should face some of the country's uncomfortable history, including that the U.S. Constitution refers to Native people as "merciless Indian savages." Megan Red Shirt-Shaw tells the Nov. 1 Common Hour audience that they should face some of the country's uncomfortable history, including that the U.S. Constitution refers to Native people as "merciless Indian savages." Image Credit: Deb Grove

Before getting too deep into the hour’s topic, Red Shirt-Shaw made sure to let the audience know that she could only speak for herself and her experiences. She asked for them not to project the responsibility of spokesperson for all indigenous peoples onto her or others with similar heritage. 

“My perspective is not on behalf of all indigenous people or nations,” she said. “I will never fairly represent the [572] federally recognized nations, the Alaska incorporations, Hawaiian communities and all of the indigenous stories across this country.” 

Red Shirt-Shaw spoke passionately on a myriad of topics related to indigenous people and identity. Of specific interest was the problematic relationship between education and Native people. From the erasure or oversimplification of Native histories and identities in American history books to the lack of representation of Native students and professors in higher education, there was much to unpack and only an hour in which to do it. 

Particularly difficult to face were the answers to “What does the U.S. Constitution say about Native people?” (they’re referred to as “merciless Indian savages”) and how the College’s founders felt about Native Americans. Benjamin Franklin, who also founded the University of Pennsylvania, where Red Shirt-Shaw received her undergraduate degree, was particularly harsh in his view on indigenous peoples. She went on to comment about how difficult it was to walk around Penn’s campus where statues of Franklin served as a reminder that its founder did not intend for somebody like her to attend his institution. 

But Red Shirt-Shaw reassured the audience that she didn’t pose these questions to make them feel guilty. “I just want you to understand what reality looks like for me as one person and what it may look like for some of your classmates,” she said.

At the heart of Red Shirt-Shaw’s message was not just that the Native people of this country continue to struggle, but that we must all work together by having uncomfortable conversations and speaking up about our own individual experiences in order to enact positive change. 

“The most powerful thing that we can show each other is that we struggle, too,” she said. “Our greatest strengths lie in holding up each other, even when we ourselves feel most defeated. That is selflessness; that is love; that is the greatest gift you can give to each other.”

Story 4/18/2019

Speaker Says Haves Get More Out of College Than Have Nots

Operation Varsity Blues, the federal sting that uncovered a bribery conspiracy among parents,...

Read More
Story 4/15/2019

F&M’s 2019 Commencement Speaker Found Her Calling in Africa

Dr. Rahel Nardos ’97will share her story about the people who mentored her and the educational...

Read More
Story 4/12/2019

Yes, Professor, the Lecture Can Evolve, Speaker Says

For those in the pedagogical set, the title, “Is the Classroom Lecture Becoming Extinct or Simply...

Read More